Skip to content

Founder's Letter · 11/11/2026

Are Structured Products Worth It? What 'Low Risk' Pays After Tax

Are structured products worth it? A founder's letter on capital-protected notes and capitalisation insurance: what they keep after costs, tax and inflation.

By Pedro Souto

Structured products, capital-protected notes and capitalisation insurance are rarely worth it for families with €2M+ at several banks: they protect the nominal euro, at maturity, if the issuer pays. With 4.0% euro-area inflation (October 2026 flash), a product taxed at 28% must earn about 5.6% a year to stand still. PWA’s investment oversight puts every product on one view, net and real; talk to Pedro about what you were sold.

The offer usually arrives on good paper. It says “low risk” and “capital protected”, it carries a fixed annual rate, and the subscription window has a closing date. It reads like a favour, and the person presenting it is usually pleasant and good at the job. I have written separately about how to evaluate an investment opportunity; this letter is about what is already in the portfolio, rather than the next proposal. When a wealthy person meets someone new, the first thought is usually: this one is going to ask me for money. Fair. I am that guy too. The difference is what I bring with it: every bank, insurer and fund you use on one page, the return measured net and real, and the risks written down where you can see them.

Are structured products worth it?

You are right that a structured product looks safe: for the nominal euro, at maturity, it usually is. As an investment, structured products are rarely worth it. The price includes the issuer’s margin and the distributor’s fee, the protection depends on the issuer paying, and a same-term sovereign bond or term deposit is simpler and easier to leave.

Two questions sit under every brochure, and the brochure rarely separates them. The first is value: what does the product deliver net of costs, after tax, after inflation and after the cost of leaving early? The second is certainty: do you know who owes you the money, how long it is locked, what leaving costs, and what else you already hold at your other banks?

A structured product is a note, deposit or fund that pairs a bond or deposit with a derivative, so its payoff follows an index, a basket or a rate by formula. The same banking group usually designs it, prices the derivative inside it and sells it. In private banking, it is the product a bank can build, price and distribute entirely in-house, which is why it arrives so often.

That is a structural incentive, not a moral one. It is the same question I set out in flat fee vs AUM and in how to check if a financial advisor is independent: who is paid when the product is sold.

The regulator’s own figures support the value question. The European Securities and Markets Authority’s eighth costs and performance report, published on 3 March 2026 with 2024 data, says structured retail product costs “remained broadly stable”, and that products maturing in 2024 “delivered positive gross returns”, figures that “do not reflect the costs paid by investors”. Interest-rate-linked structured products reached 27% of the market in 2024, up from 1% in 2021. That puts them in direct comparison with a term deposit or a Treasury bill of the same term.

There is an honest exception. A protected payoff can be right when it matches a known liability on a known date, such as a property payment in four years, and when it has been priced in writing against the plain alternative. Putting that comparison on one page is the job of investment oversight, and it is the first thing I build.

What is the difference between capital guaranteed and capital protected?

The two words do sound the same, and brochures use them as if they were. “Guaranteed” usually means a third party (the issuing bank, an insurer or a deposit-guarantee scheme up to its limit) promises the nominal capital at maturity. “Protected” usually means the structure aims to return it, with no outside promise. Neither covers inflation or an early exit.

Capital protected products are notes, deposits and funds built so that, held to maturity, they return a stated share of the amount invested: often 100%, sometimes 90% or 95%. What matters is who stands behind that share, and on what date.

The deposit guarantee is the clearest line. Under the EU Deposit Guarantee Schemes Directive, each depositor’s aggregate deposits at a bank are covered up to €100,000. A deposit, in the directive’s definition, is a balance repaid at par; a balance whose existence can only be proven by a financial instrument, such as a security, falls outside it. A structured deposit is therefore covered; a capital-protected note is not. Insurance contracts are not deposits at all: their promise rests on the insurer’s solvency, under insurance supervision (the ASF in Portugal, the DGSFP in Spain).

Product classWho stands behind the capitalDeposit guarantee (€100,000)?Leaving before maturityWhat “protection” covers
Term depositThe bankYesUsually possible, with interest forfeitedNominal capital and the agreed rate
Structured depositThe bankYesOften not allowed, or at a costNominal capital at maturity; the return follows a formula
Capital-protected structured noteThe issuer, as unsecured debtNoAt the price the issuer quotesA stated share of nominal capital at maturity, if the issuer pays
Fund sold as “capital-guaranteed”A named guarantor, usually a bankNoAt net asset value, often with an exit feeNominal capital on the guarantee date only
Capitalisation insurance with a technical rateThe insurer’s general fund and solvencyNoSurrender value, with charges in the early yearsPremiums and the promised rate, if the insurer pays
Unit-linked insuranceNobody: the holder carries the market riskNoUnit value, less surrender chargesNothing, unless a specific option is bought

The value question is what each row pays after costs, tax and inflation. The certainty question is the name in the second column, and how much of the family’s money already sits with that name elsewhere. Both answers belong on one page, beside everything else the family holds; that page is where my work starts.

Net and real: what a ‘low-risk’ product keeps after costs, tax and inflation

The rate does look attractive, and on paper it beats a sight account. After costs, tax on the gain and 4.0% inflation, it has to clear about 5.6% a year just to stand still. Three subtractions decide what it keeps: costs come off first, tax comes off at redemption, and inflation comes off every year.

Take the return after costs, keep the share tax leaves you, and subtract inflation:

real net return ≈ nominal return × (1 − tax rate on the gain) − inflation

It is a simplification that ignores compounding and tax deferral, but it sorts products well enough. Turned around, the return needed to break even is inflation ÷ (1 − tax rate). At 4.0% inflation and 28% tax, that is 4.0 ÷ 0.72 = 5.56%.

Costs come first because some figures are quoted before them. The cost layers, including the retrocession (the share of a product’s fee the manufacturer pays back to the distributor), are set out in hidden private banking fees and retrocessions.

Tax depends on the wrapper and the country. In Portugal, capital income such as deposit interest is taxed at the 28% liberatory rate of Article 71 of the CIRS. For life insurance and capitalisation contracts, Article 5(3) excludes one-fifth of the gain from tax after five years and three-fifths after eight, provided at least 35% of the premiums were paid in the first half of the contract. That gives effective rates of 22.4% and 11.2%. In Spain, where the policyholder is also the beneficiary, gains on a savings insurance redemption are capital income taxed on the savings scale, which runs from 19% to 30% (Articles 25.3 and 66 of the IRPF law, 2025 tax year). Confirm the treatment of your own contract with your tax advisor.

InflationTaxed at 28% (PT, under 5 years)22.4% effective (PT, 5–8 years)11.2% effective (PT, over 8 years)
2%2.78%2.58%2.25%
3%4.17%3.87%3.38%
4%5.56%5.15%4.50%

Gross annual return, after costs, needed to match inflation after tax on the gain. Break-even = inflation ÷ (1 − tax rate). Tax rates: CIRS Articles 5(3) and 71.

The table runs from 2% to 4% on purpose. Euro-area inflation averaged 2.4% in 2024 and 2.1% in 2025. October 2026 is a spike: Eurostat’s flash estimate is 4.0%, up from 3.8% in September, driven by energy at 20.8%, while core inflation held at 2.5%. The flash figures for Portugal and Spain are 3.9% and 4.9%. At the calm end of the range, a product taxed at 28% still needs about 2.8% after costs.

What the same euro earns elsewhere, as public yardsticks:

  • Euro-area new household deposits with an agreed maturity of up to one year paid 2.33% in September 2026 (ECB, 2 November 2026).
  • Portuguese Certificados de Aforro Série F carry a 2.5% gross base rate for November 2026 subscriptions (IGCP, 30 October 2026).
  • Spanish 12-month Letras del Tesoro priced at a 3.045% average yield at the 3 November 2026 auction (Tesoro Público).

None of them clears 4.0% after tax either. A product with a lock-up, an issuer and a formula has to beat these, not a sight account. This is opportunity cost, not a recommendation: it is the comparison to ask for in writing, over the same term, net of tax.

The outcomes are on record. EIOPA’s costs and past performance report, published on 1 April 2026, found that low-to-medium-risk profit-participation and unit-linked products returned 1.5% and 2.2% a year on average over 2020–2024, net of costs and before inflation. Euro-area inflation over those five years compounded to about 3.8% a year (our calculation from Eurostat’s annual averages). Higher-risk unit-linked products did beat inflation over the same period. The low-risk ones, on average, did not.

If you hold one of these and have never seen it restated this way, talk to Pedro about the net, real return on what you hold.

Capitalisation insurance and unit-linked: what the insurance wrapper changes

The insurance wrapper does offer something real: it changes who stands behind the money, when tax is due and how the contract passes on death. It does not change what the money inside earns, and the promise is only as strong as the insurer.

The value question here is the return of what sits inside, after the wrapper’s own costs. EIOPA’s April 2026 report found unit-linked costs fell by 8 basis points on average in 2024, and that costs vary significantly across providers, so the answer is contract by contract. The certainty question is which of two mechanisms you hold.

  1. Capitalisation insurance with a technical rate (profit participation). Premiums go into the insurer’s general fund. The insurer promises a minimum rate and shares part of the fund’s surplus. The rate is the insurer’s promise, backed by its solvency, and surrender charges apply in the early years.
  2. Unit-linked insurance. Premiums buy units of funds. The holder carries the market risk in full, and there is no capital promise unless a specific option is bought and paid for.

The English-market names for the same idea are capitalisation contract, capital redemption bond and insurance bond. The disadvantages of a capital redemption bond are the ones above: costs inside and outside the wrapper, surrender charges, the insurer’s credit, and a tax advantage that depends on holding period and residence.

What to read is already in your files. Under the PRIIPs Regulation (EU) No 1286/2014, every packaged retail and insurance-based investment product carries a key information document of at most three sides of A4. It must show total aggregate costs in money and percentage terms, and performance scenarios. Read the unfavourable and stress scenarios first: a stress test shows what a position is worth under a severe but plausible shock, and since 1 January 2023 the stress scenario may not show a better value than the unfavourable one.

The planning angle can be the real reason to hold one. Tax timing, the beneficiary clause and the contract’s treatment on succession are structuring questions for the family’s tax and legal advisors. Through wealth planning and structuring, PWA coordinates that conversation and puts the answers in writing; it does not decide it.

If an insurance contract is part of your family’s plan and nobody has restated it net and real, talk to Pedro about the insurance contracts you hold.

Five risks the brochure does not lead with

Your banker is probably right that each product, on its own, is low risk. The risks sit in what the brochure prints last and in what no single bank adds up. There are five, and each has a date, a name or a number you can ask for in writing.

  1. Lock-up and early-exit cost. Protection applies at maturity. Before it, the issuer is usually the only buyer and makes the price, and an insurer applies a surrender charge. So are structured products liquid? You can usually leave, but on the issuer’s terms, not the market’s.
  2. Issuer and insurer credit risk. A capital-protected note is the bank’s unsecured debt, outside the €100,000 deposit guarantee. An insurance promise is only as good as the insurer’s solvency. Holding notes and deposits above the guarantee at the same bank stacks two exposures on one name.
  3. Conditional protection and capped upside. Barriers, partial protection at 90% or 95%, and participation rates below 100% mean a “protected” product may pay neither the market’s gain nor the deposit’s rate.
  4. Opportunity cost. The euro is locked for years at terms set today. Compare it with the yardsticks above over the same term: 2.33% on euro-area deposits up to one year in September 2026, 3.045% on Spanish 12-month bills in November.
  5. The same bet at several banks. Three banks’ notes on the same equity index, plus the same index inside each discretionary mandate (where the bank decides the investments within agreed limits) and each unit-linked fund, add up to one position nobody totals. That is concentration risk: too much of the family’s balance sheet depending on one issuer, index or market. Seeing it needs look-through, reading through funds and wrappers to the underlying holdings, the same exercise as in AI concentration risk.

Protection is a promise about the nominal euro, on one date, from one issuer.

Nobody adds up the same index across three banks. That is the risk.

The same index at three banks, and no one adding it up?

Send Pedro the product list from each bank and insurer, with maturities. The first conversation maps issuers, exit dates and overlap, not a pitch.

Talk to Pedro about one view of your products

One view, net and real: how I check what a family has been sold

You do not need a better product to answer this. You need every product on one page, net and real, with its risks written next to it. That page is the investment oversight I provide, built on consolidated reporting across every bank and insurer.

The work has five parts:

  1. Inventory. Every structured product, insurance contract, fund sold as “capital-guaranteed” and mandate, at every bank and insurer, taken from statements and key information documents.
  2. Net and real. Each product’s return restated after costs, tax and inflation, against the yardsticks above and a stated benchmark, the reference return a holding is measured against, over the same term.
  3. Risk map. Maturity and exit dates, exposure by issuer and insurer name, and overlap by underlying index, placed on the family balance sheet, the one statement of everything the family owns and owes.
  4. Written questions. The questions the family sends each bank and insurer: exit price, exit cost, total costs, issuer, tax clock.
  5. Coordination. The family’s tax and legal advisors on any decision to hold or leave, with the reasoning recorded.

The method is the one in consolidated reporting across multiple banks, applied to products rather than accounts. A bank’s free portfolio review prices its own products; this view prices all of them against each other. The EIOPA figures above are averages across providers whose costs differ widely; a family holds specific contracts.

PWA does not manage money, hold mandates, take commissions or give regulated investment, tax or legal advice. The work is paid by the family, and only by the family, which is the point of independent oversight of private banks. What I hand over is a written second opinion on what the family holds and the questions it raises, never a trade.

I said at the start that I am also the one who asks for money. What I ask for it is the statements, and what I give back is one page you can read. Talk to Pedro about what you were sold.

Questions we hear

Are structured notes and principal protected notes a good investment?

They can look like the best of both worlds, and for the nominal capital at maturity a protected note can deliver it. As an investment they rarely beat the plain alternative: the note is the issuer’s unsecured debt, the upside is usually capped, and selling early means accepting the issuer’s price. Measure it net and real against a sovereign bond of the same term, on one consolidated view.

Are structured products liquid? Can I exit before maturity?

They feel liquid because you can usually leave before maturity, but only on the issuer’s terms. The protection applies only at maturity; before it, the issuer is usually the only buyer and sets the price, and insurance contracts add surrender charges. Ask each bank in writing for today’s exit price and exit cost, and record both on one view.

Is a structured deposit covered by the deposit guarantee, and is a capital-protected note?

The instinct to check is right, and the answer differs by product. A structured deposit is a deposit repaid at par, so the deposit guarantee covers it up to €100,000 per depositor per bank, across all deposits there. A capital-protected note is a security and the issuer’s unsecured debt, so it does not. Map both by issuer.

How is a capitalisation insurance (seguro de capitalização) taxed on redemption in Portugal?

The deferral is real. Under Articles 5(3) and 71 of the CIRS, the gain is capital income taxed at redemption at the 28% liberatory rate; one-fifth is excluded after five years and three-fifths after eight, if at least 35% of premiums were paid in the contract’s first half. Restate the return on that basis, and confirm with your tax advisor.

Are insurance bonds or capital redemption bonds a good investment?

The wrapper is useful for tax timing and the beneficiary clause, so the appeal is real. As an investment it is only as good as what sits inside: EIOPA reports low-to-medium-risk profit-participation products returned 1.5% a year, net and nominal, over 2020–2024, below euro-area inflation for those years. Ask for the key information document’s costs and stress scenario, and compare it on one consolidated view, net and real.

How do I calculate the real rate of return after tax and inflation?

The quoted rate is a fair starting point, but it is not what you keep. Subtract costs, multiply by one minus the tax rate on the gain, then subtract inflation. At 4.0% inflation and 28% tax, a product must pay about 5.6% to stand still. Run every product through the same formula, on one consolidated view.

Should I compare a structured deposit with Certificados de Aforro or Treasury bonds?

Yes, and the instinct is right. Compare over the same term, net of tax: in November 2026 the Certificados de Aforro Série F base rate was 2.5% gross, and euro-area household deposits up to one year paid 2.33% in September 2026. Ask the bank to show the structured deposit against both, in writing, on one consolidated view.

Sources

All pages opened and checked on 11 November 2026.

  • Eurostat, “Euro area annual inflation up to 4.0%”, flash estimate, 4 November 2026. Supports: euro area 4.0% (October 2026), 3.8% (September), energy 20.8%, core 2.5%, Portugal 3.9%, Spain 4.9%; full data due 18 November 2026. ec.europa.eu
  • Eurostat, HICP annual average rate of change (prc_hicp_aind), euro area, updated 6 February 2026. Supports: 0.3% (2020), 2.6% (2021), 8.4% (2022), 5.4% (2023), 2.4% (2024), 2.1% (2025); the 2020–2024 compound average of about 3.8% a year is our calculation. ec.europa.eu
  • European Central Bank, “Euro area bank interest rate statistics: September 2026”, 2 November 2026. Supports: 2.33% on new household deposits with agreed maturity up to one year. ecb.europa.eu
  • IGCP, “Taxas de juro dos Certificados de Aforro … em novembro de 2026”, 30 October 2026. Supports: Série F gross base rate 2.500% for November 2026. igcp.pt
  • Tesoro Público, “Resultado últimas subastas: Letras del Tesoro”, auction of 3 November 2026. Supports: 12-month average yield 3.045%. tesoro.es
  • ESMA, “New investment funds drive reduction in costs for investors”, 3 March 2026 (eighth costs and performance report, 2024 data). Supports: structured retail product costs “remained broadly stable”; matured products’ gross returns “do not reflect the costs paid by investors”; interest-rate-linked share 27% (1% in 2021). esma.europa.eu
  • EIOPA, “EIOPA report shows overall positive net returns, although wide variation amongst products underscores…”, 1 April 2026. Supports: 1.5% (profit participation) and 2.2% (unit-linked) a year, low-to-medium risk, net, 2020–2024; higher-risk unit-linked outperformed inflation; unit-linked costs down 8 basis points on average in 2024; costs vary significantly across providers. eiopa.europa.eu
  • Autoridade Tributária, Código do IRS, Article 5 (version to December 2022). Supports: life insurance gains as capital income; one-fifth excluded after five and before eight years, three-fifths after eight; 35% premium condition. portaldasfinancas.gov.pt
  • Autoridade Tributária, Código do IRS, Article 71 (version to December 2024). Supports: 28% liberatory rate on capital income. portaldasfinancas.gov.pt
  • Agencia Tributaria, Manual práctico de Renta 2025, “Gravamen de la base liquidable del ahorro” (Article 66 of Ley 35/2006). Supports: savings scale from 19% to 30%. sede.agenciatributaria.gob.es
  • Agencia Tributaria, Manual práctico de Renta 2025, “Rendimientos procedentes de operaciones de capitalización y de contratos de seguro de vida o invalidez” (savings-base section) (Article 25.3 of Ley 35/2006). Supports: insurance and capitalisation gains are capital income in the savings base where policyholder and beneficiary are the same person. sede.agenciatributaria.gob.es
  • Directive 2014/49/EU on deposit guarantee schemes, Articles 2(1)(3) and 6(1). Supports: €100,000 coverage per depositor; deposits repayable at par; balances proven only by a financial instrument excluded. eur-lex.europa.eu
  • Fondo de Garantía de Depósitos de Entidades de Crédito (Spain). Supports: up to €100,000 per holder and institution. fgd.es
  • Regulation (EU) No 1286/2014 (PRIIPs), Articles 6(4) and 8(3). Supports: key information document of at most three sides of A4; performance scenarios; total aggregate costs in money and percentage terms. eur-lex.europa.eu
  • EIOPA, Q&A 3102 (PRIIPs 180) on Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/653, Annex IV point 20. Supports: from 1 January 2023 the stress scenario may not show a better value than the unfavourable scenario. eiopa.europa.eu

Pedro Souto is the founder of PWA — Private Wealth Advisory. He works with UHNW founders, families, and single-family offices to build an independent operating layer around complex wealth — combining markets, analytics, technology, and governance to turn fragmented advice into one coherent picture, and to make someone, finally, responsible for the whole of it.

— Next step

Several banks, several low-risk products, and no one totalling them?

Send Pedro the statements and key information documents. The first conversation sets out what each product keeps after costs, tax and inflation, and what to ask each bank in writing.